Home

Adoption Under One Roof

Covering adoption from every angle, every view, for everyone

Read the Traumatized Child Blog. Use AUOR for 10% Discount at Dream Catcher

Main Menu

  • Home
  • How To Adopt
    • Getting Started With Adoption
    • Adoption Types, Costs, Timeline
    • Hague Intercountry Adoption Treaty
    • Definition of Adoption Terms
  • Resources
    • Foster Care
      • Contests
    • After Adoption
      • Searching for a Birthmother
    • Adoption Statistics
  • Blogs
    • Guest Blogger
      • Dee Thompson
      • Janine
      • Jeanette Schnell
      • John
        • Older Child Adoption
        • humpty series-older child adoption
      • Linda Lach
      • Linny
      • Marjorie Shaw
        • A Legitimate Life: A Forbidden Journey of Self Discovery
      • Michael
      • Patricia Dischler
      • Scrapsbynobody
      • Shelia Davis
      • Susan Metters
    • Adoption Maharishi
    • Amy Adoptee
    • AngelaW
    • Ask An Adoptee
    • FaithA
      • Baby Names
      • Trauma Thursday
      • Trauma Tuesday
    • Foster Mommy
      • Educational Testing and Assessments
      • Friday Activities
    • Julia Fuller
      • Fetal Alcohol Syndrome Diaries
      • Parenting Mistakes Saturday
    • JulieC
      • Friday Funnies
      • How To Tuesday
        • How To Tuesday
      • Hump Day Hippie
      • JulieC's Sites to See
    • LisaS
      • Chanuka is not Christmas with a twist, teaching your adopted child's friends about Chanukah,
      • Corrupt and Questionable Adoption Agencies
      • Making the World a Better Place
      • Running With Scissors
    • Sandra Hanks Benoiton
  • Polls
  • About Us
    • Blog and Comment Posting Policy
    • Contact Us
Home Blogs SandraHanksBenoiton's blog

Art? Hm ... Deffo not adoption, though

Submitted by SandraHanksBenoiton on Tue, 04/28/2009 - 03:57
  • Africa
  • art
  • Celebrity Adoption
  • film
  • Intercountry adoption
  • International adoption
  • News
  • Orphans
  • Sudan
  • Vanessa Beecroft

Not art either

Opening caveat: This is not about international adoption.

The story that follows is no more about adoption than was last year's Zoe's Ark fiasco.

Now that that's out of the way, we can all spend a few minutes being appalled while I attempt to head off any tarrings of adoption with the brush so publicly wielded at the pass. It's this story titled, "An artist's ego ... and adoption" that winds my spring this morning, starting off as it does ...

Angelina Jolie and Madonna have adopted African babies. Have they started a trend? That's just one of the ideas investigated in The Art Star and the Sudanese Twins, a terrific new documentary about performance artist Vanessa Beecroft and the African infants she wanted to call her own.

Okay, that's the hook, and it does move beyond the dangling bait, but like by the subject of the piece herself, the "A" word is used for milage.

I've written elsewhere about art reduced to objectification and obscenity, but now that the film is getting press again, it's time to move past the headlines and pay some attention to the fact that no matter how this package is wrapped, it is still not about adoption.

Sure, there are orphans somewhere near the plot, local dignitaries, international lawyers and rigmarole, but these are little more than props for photo ops trotted out by a mercenary.

The picture of Beecroft that slowly comes together is one of ruthless ego and bizarre sentiment. There are a handful of moments in the movie that cut painfully close to the heart of Beecroft's character -- a chat about a childhood friend she tormented for being stupid and ugly, for example, the way she hisses at her assistant, or her seeming indifference to the people around her. In one memorable scene, Beecroft is interrupted during a photo shoot by women in the village who object, strenuously, to the babies being naked in the church. She barricades the door against the women -- in their village, in their church, with their orphans.

There shouldn't be a need to point out that there is no logical link between adoption and the abomination that is the Vanessa Beecroft/ Sudanese twins thing, but having been around the block more than a few times, I suspect attempts at forging one.

Although I do agree with Oscar Wilde's quote, "Bad art is a great deal worse than no art at all", as commentary it might be better if some people just shut up, and perhaps mangling Woody Allen works better in today's world: "Art doesn't imitate life, it imitates bad television."

Or, as parenthetically added to the story today, Damien Hirst's words that could be put into a thought bubble above the shots of Beecroft dressed to the nines in white, blondy and pasty, with a black baby on each breast: "I can't wait to get into a position to make really bad art and get away with it."

 

Photo credit: Not art either/ Sandra Hanks

  • SandraHanksBenoiton's blog
  • Login or register to post comments

The Connected Child:
Bring hope and healing
to your adoptive family

buy from amazon

 

User login

  • Create new account
  • Request new password

Popular content

Today's:

  • Update on Baby Vanessa’s Birthfather who is Fighting for her Custody
  • Adoption Poem
  • Difficult Adopted Child and Frustration with Other People Not “Getting It”

All time:

  • International Adoption Statistics for 2007
  • Trauma Tuesday: Orgasms During Rape and Sexual Abuse
  • Guest Blog: Humpty Dumpty Had a Great Fall - I’m Outta Here

Last viewed:

  • Pre-Adoption Fears
  • Update on Baby Vanessa’s Birthfather who is Fighting for her Custody
  • Trauma Thursday: What Does a Flashback Feel Like?

Recent comments

  • ART [The DHS. Adption
    3 hours 18 min ago
  • both bad guys
    6 hours 21 min ago
  • Uh, no
    16 hours 28 min ago
  • ART - A Blue October's Moonlight Hire
    1 day 26 min ago
  • ART - Adoption's Real Triad
    3 hours 54 min ago
  • A Point of View
    3 days 1 hour ago
  • Selective reading
    3 days 6 hours ago
  • Greetings from Guatemala
    4 days 7 hours ago
  • A Garden State poem
    4 days 23 hours ago
  • You're doing the right thing
    5 days 6 hours ago
Site Map
© 2010 Adoption Under One Roof LLC. All Rights Reserved. email: info at ouradopt.com
Opinions expressed in posts and blogs belong to the person who is expressing them. So then it follows that these opinions are not those of Adoption Under One Roof.
RoopleTheme