Anti-adoption
My Response to: Adoptees of Color Roundtable Speak Out Against Haitian Adoption and Intercountry Adoption in General
It has taken me a few days to get around to responding to this article, partly because I have been fighting a bad case of the flu and its aftereffects and partly because, well, it sounds annoyingly familiar. Over the last three years that I’ve been blogging about intercountry adoption, I’ve heard several adoptees of intercountry adoption speak out against adoption. I respect their right to state their opinion and support the freedom of speech our country legislates, but unfortunately I have to disagree with most of what they claim.
Take for example these statements:
For more than fifty years "orphaned children" have been shipped from areas of war, natural disasters, and poverty to supposedly better lives in Europe and North America. Our adoptions from Vietnam, South Korea, Guatemala and many other countries are no different from what is happening to the children of Haiti today. Like us, these "disaster orphans" will grow into adulthood and begin to grasp the magnitude of the abuse, fraud, negligence, suffering, and deprivation of human rights involved in their displacements.
Here is one group of adoptees who have decided to be the spokespeople for all intercountry adoptees. They see themselves as victims and they warn future adoptees that their future is doomed if they are adopted as well. In their opinion, intercountry adoption is nothing more than abuse, fraud, suffering etc. This is a huge exaggeration.
- LisaS's blog
- Login or register to post comments
- Read more
Year End Blog Summary: The Good the Bad and the Ugly of 2009
"Always report the positive things first,” said the wise principal of the last high school where I taught ESL over two decades ago in preparation for parent - teacher meetings. Following that line of psychology, I’ll start my summary of 2009 with the good.
The good (and some great) things in my adoption blog world in 2009
People kept reading my blogs on Adoption Under One Roof and occasionally posting comments – ah, the wisdom in some of these comments is priceless.
More incredible people came into my life through blogging about adoption: adoptees, adoptive parents, birth parents, foster parents and good people with little or no connection to adoption.
By posting a novel in segments, I became friends with an intelligent, insightful and helpful woman who has taught me much about the “other side:”
Generous and brilliant bloggers continued to respond to my requests for guestblogs gaining nothing in return but a thank you and a link to their websites. These guestbloggers (and others who are recruited by Julia and Faith who I’ve tried to include in my list) contributed diverse opinions, important and useful information and some even made us laugh in the process.
So a huge thanks to these wonderful guestbloggers: Amy, David, Dee, Eva, Janine, Jeanette, Jennifer, John, Lee, Melanie, Melinda, Melissa, Michael, Patricia, Paula, Scraps, Snafu Suz, Suki, and Suzanne.
- LisaS's blog
- Login or register to post comments
- Read more
A Bee up my Butt on Adoption: Gloomy Forecast for 2010
Fully expecting the international adoption situation to continue to disintegrate over this year as it has over the past few, starting 2010 off with some common sense thoughts on the topic seems a good idea. Easy enough today, with this in the news:
Police in Nigeria have arrested a doctor suspected of impregnating girls and selling their babies. The police said they found five pregnant girls aged between 12 and 17 at the doctor's clinic in the south-eastern town of Enugu. The police said the man had confessed to getting the girls pregnant and selling their children. He is to face charges in court. Trafficking is common in Nigeria, with children sold for labour and sex work. In 2008, police raided a private hospital in Enugu which they said was a "baby farm". Seven pregnant young women were found.
Child Abduction in China
One of the poop nuggets often dragged out by those opposed to international adoption is that western families hoping to bring a child into their fold prompt abductions from birth families in poor countries.
That this sometimes substantiated, but often not, allegation misses the point is clear to anyone who spends time in poverty stricken places, as child abandonment and lots of other nasty stuff are facts of life when disease, starvation, war and other realities abound.
As this from the BBC illustrates, there is a side to this coin, as well, one that is never mentioned while adoption-bashing: bad people stealing children for profit is not an adoption issue, nor is it adoption-driven, but a crime that carried out all the time without international adoption having a thing to do with it.
In China, a country that has made international adoption more and more difficult as it touts its ability to keep its house in order, thousands of children are being kidnapped and sold to Chinese families in need of boys to fill their ancestral obligations.
- SandraHanksBenoiton's blog
- Login or register to post comments
- Read more
Sandra Speaks out Against Anti-Adoption Rhetoric of Mirah Riben

I would love to address the content of this article, a new offering from anti-adoption banger Mirah Riben, but I first must pull out the blue pencil and do so many corrections of the grammar and punctuation that it will take more effort than the piece is worth.
The fact that Mirah continues to be published even with such poor writing skills speaks to the vociferousness of the anti league, and to a lack of observational and comprehension skills. This makes it so easy to cherry pick random quotes, arrange them in a barely readable mishmash and pass the whole thing off as information, and when preaching to the choir that is all that is necessary.
Trotting out unsubstantiated numbers helps, too:
"These fears, myths and misconceptions, coupled with the glamorization of rescuing orphans, are perpetrated by an adoption industry that generates an estimated 6.3 billion annually worldwide and 23 billion domestically."
- SandraHanksBenoiton's blog
- Login or register to post comments
- Read more
Intercountry Adoption and AIDS Orphans

Worldwide there are an estimated 15 million children under the age of 18 that have been orphaned as a result of AIDS with 11.6 million of these children living in sub-Saharan Africa. Their life becomes a nightmare when they have to care for a sick and dying parent and explodes into a full blown tragedy when these children are left to fend for themselves.
As the number of parents dying of AIDS increases, fewer children have anyone to care for them when their parents are dead. Members of the extended families who traditionally would be the safety net for these newly orphaned children are taxed to the limit taking in orphaned relatives. More children are left on their own, the eldest being responsible for the wellbeing of younger siblings.
In addition to the emotional trauma of watching their parents die and becoming orphans, these children rarely have access to a reliable source of food, a home to live in, education and health care. It is not uncommon for them to be stigmatized because their parents have died of AIDS and consequently denied access to services that may be available to other children. Even those children who are left land or assets by their parents rarely get anything as relatives quickly step in and grab whatever is left behind.
Husband Would Rather Divorce Than Adopt A Child
One of our readers is dealing with a serious but not uncommon dilemma – a husband who is unwilling to adopt, and would rather divorce than adopt.
It is not unusual for men to be more reticent about adoption for a multitude of reasons. If for example the reason for adoption is a result of infertility, he may need more time to accept the losses that are associated with infertility, especially if he was diagnosed as infertile. Some men don’t want a child that is not biologically related to them, a child that won’t continue the family lineage.
What Is Life Like for Orphans in India?
I met a young missionary family named the Lehman’s while on vacation last month. They live in Delhi India, where they serve that community on a large hospital complex where Dr. Jeff Lehman serves as a missionary family doctor. They are raising their own four young children there while treating the poor, the aids affected, the orphans, and other impoverished residents. Mrs. Leman says that infants, usually girls who are considered less important, are frequently left behind in the hospital. While her heart aches to take each one home, she cannot legally do so. Dr. Leman told us that the average income in the poor areas of India is about 50 cents a day. Seventy percent of the children born in India suffer from malnutrition.
- JuliaFuller's blog
- Login or register to post comments
- Read more
Missions Help Children Stay in Their Country of Origin
My 16-year-old son is currently in Tegucigalpa Honduras with 30 other area residents helping children and families improve their lives. The group, led by a local Christian radio station, took an entire playground with them. The playground was garbage here; a school gave it to them. The team members, including my son, spent hours in a factory sanding and repainting the playground equipment. The team also took school desk, that my family and area youth groups, cleaned, disassembled, and painted. These were gladly donated as they were headed to a local iron and metal foundry. The team will be providing home improvement projects for area families, you can check out some of the photos posted on the way.fm website if you are curious about the living conditions. One home they are remodeling is 10-feet by 15-feet, and houses a family of six. The floor has large boulders and the team will be smoothing it out and pouring concrete for the family. Check out this video clip to see missions in action, helping these Honduran children stay in their country of origin.
- JuliaFuller's blog
- Login or register to post comments
- Read more
Opportunities to Help Orphans Stay and Thrive in Their Countries of Origin
Orphan Outreach is a nonprofit organization with headquarters in Dallas, Texas that is helping orphans stay in their countries of origin. Not just by feeding them food, but also feeding their minds, and helping their families. The organization is setting up schools to educate these children and putting up playgrounds to offer safe places for children to play and dream. Currently Orphan Outreach has children ministries in Guatemala, Honduras, India, and Russia and they need your help. If you strongly believe that children should be kept in their country of origin than consider traveling to one of these countries in the next 12 months and helping.





Recent comments
3 hours 58 min ago
1 day 20 hours ago
1 day 21 hours ago
2 days 15 hours ago
2 days 18 hours ago
2 days 23 hours ago
3 days 1 hour ago
5 days 19 hours ago
6 days 9 hours ago
6 days 17 hours ago